German court convicts Skype of GPL breach
Published: 25 Jul 2007 16:04 BST
A German court has ruled that Skype violated the General Public License version 2 by selling a Linux-based phone without access to the source code.
Skype sells the WSKP100 phone, made by SMC, in various countries, including the UK and Germany, but it does not give every user access to the source code, as the GPLv2 open-source licence would require.
Read this
FAQ: Why you should care about GPLv3
The open-source community has seen an update to the licence that underpins most of its developments. Here's what you need to know about it...
In response to legal action from the gpl-violations.org project, a website run by software developer Harald Welte, Skype included a flyer in the package giving a web link to the source code, but it was still not strictly in compliance with GPLv2, the court in Munich ruled — apparently because it did not include the GPL licence itself.
The minor breach will not take Skype off the air, or even cause it to stop selling the phone, but it must make minor changes to the way it sells the phone. Gpl-violations.org is also apparently taking action against SMC itself. The phone in question is sold in the UK by Skype and Wi-Fi hotspot operator The Cloud, among others.
Welte's organisation has contested hundreds of similar breaches of the GPL in products including attached storage and laptops. Most cases have been settled out of court, with the vendor paying gpl-violations.org's costs, and mending its ways. Welte leads netfilter, the packet-filtering framework inside the Linux 2.4.x and 2.6.x kernel.
Sun exec accuses Microsoft of 'patent terrorism'
James Eagleton says the software giant's recent agreements with Linux distributors are 'against the spirit of innovation around software' [24 Jul 2007]
Linux gets broader virtualisation support
Xen and lguest technologies have both been merged directly into the Linux kernel, opening up more virtualisation avenues [23 Jul 2007]
Linspire Linux deal 'worse than Novell'
Microsoft's patent agreement with the Linux distributor shuts out GPLv3 and makes Linspire unsuitable for business, claims legal expert [23 Jul 2007]
Intel aims to speed Linux gadget development
New site is designed to spur development of OS for improved mobile web surfing, networking, power management, user interface and more [17 Jul 2007]
Second open Linux phone on sale
FIC's fully hackable Neo1973 handset is officially launched for developers, with a 'mass market' launch of the OpenMoko system due later this year [09 Jul 2007]
GPLv3 may not bind Microsoft
A leading lawyer has claimed that the software giant should be able to extricate itself from the implications of GPLv3 [25 Jul 2007]
Microsoft claims immunity from GPLv3
Software giant has issued a statement distancing itself from the latest version of the GPL, apparently in a attempt to escape liabilities that may arise when Novell adopts it [06 Jul 2007]
Free Software Foundation releases GPLv3
The new licence adjusts to software industry changes but carries several new provisions [02 Jul 2007]
GPLv3 is more than a licence
The General Public License has been updated for the 21st century. The community knows what it wants, and won't give it up [02 Jul 2007]
A GNU dawn for open source
The release of GPLv3 on Friday caused widespread controversy following Microsoft's series of pacts with a host of Linux vendors [02 Jul 2007]
Why you should care about GPLv3
The open-source community has just seen an update to the licence that underpins most of its developments [07 Jun 2007]
Stallman touts GPLv3 provisions
Digital rights management and patent protection are important reasons for developers to upgrade to GPLv3, says FSF founder Richard Stallman [04 Jun 2007]
Inside the Microsoft-Novell deal
Microsoft's upper management seem keen on the adage 'keep your friends close but your enemies closer' — particularly in the case of Novell [30 Apr 2007]
Moglen resigns as FSF director
One of the main forces behind the development of the GPL is stepping down from the Free Software Foundation to concentrate on working for the Software Freedom Law Centre [26 Apr 2007]
Video: Torvalds on DRM and GPLv3
In part one of a five-part interview, Linus Torvalds talks about why digital rights management and the GPL cause a lot of 'hot air' to be exchanged [24 Jan 2007]
Torvalds: GPLv3 is 'just another licence'
DRM and the GPL may be at the centre of heated debates, but the Linux creator is confident 'good technology' will win in the end [17 Jan 2007]
Did you find this article useful?
39 out of 43 people found this useful
- Share this article:
