South Africa embraces open source
Published: 05 Feb 2003 11:10 GMT
Joining a lengthening list of governments, South Africa has adopted an official policy promoting the use of open-source software -- but stopped short of jettisoning proprietary applications.
The new policy by Africa's wealthiest nation expresses a preference for open-source applications when proprietary alternatives don't offer a compelling advantage. Other nations have taken more extreme positions, mandating the use of open-source software unless no other practical alternatives exist.
"The primary criteria for selecting software solutions will remain the improvement of efficiency, effectiveness and economy of service delivery by (the) government to its citizens," reads the policy, which was drafted last month and published Monday in a final version. "OSS (open-source software) offers significant indirect advantages. Where the direct advantages and disadvantages of OSS and PS (proprietary software) are equally strong, and where circumstances in the specific situation do not render it inappropriate, opting for OSS will be preferable."
Elsewhere in the policy, the government pledged to promote "fair and impartial treatment" of open-source software in procurement, create "opportunities for trial use," and take advantage of "the opportunities presented by the OSS movement to promote access to information for citizens."
Behind the comparatively moderate policy lie serious grievances with the way the proprietary software development and marketing model has treated South Africa and countries like it.
By and large, South Africa imports its proprietary software and finds itself with comparatively little influence on how that software develops. The government expects that open-source software, by contrast, will provide more flexibility.
"In the case of many open-source solutions, it may still be a case that the original development was not done specifically with the South African environment in mind, but in this paradigm we are in a position to take action...further by adapting/extending it to our unique needs," said Sibusiso Sibisi, chief executive of the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research, a South African science and technology group that claims credit for 10 percent of all research and development work done on the African continent.
"It is when a country or community is at the mercy of a technology provider, and powerless to determine or shape its own fate, that the situation becomes problematic and an intervention is required," Sibisi added.
The government is the largest single buyer of computer technology in South Africa, so its actions are watched closely by both open-source advocates and proprietary software venders, particularly Microsoft.
Government policies favouring or mandating the use of open-source software have become one of the most important open-source fires Microsoft has strived to put out over the past few years. Such policies have proliferated in the developing world, where state budgets are particularly limited. But the legislative movement in favour of open source has also made inroads within the United States. Microsoft has lobbied strenuously against the trend.
"All customers -- including government customers -- should make decisions about which type of software to implement based upon a careful analysis of the long-term value that the software provides," said Alex Mercer, a Microsoft spokeswoman. "We agree with this view and do work with industry partners and organisations...to encourage governments to keep their software options open by adhering to policies that do not favour one software development model over another."
Mercer cited the United Kingdom's open-source policy, which reads in part: "There is a need to always procure a solution that gives value for money. This may be an OSS solution, or proprietary one, or a mixture of both. Decisions should be made on a case-by-case basis."
Microsoft has taken a keen interest in the developing African information technology market, but the open-source movement has already stymied its efforts there.
In November, SchoolNet Namibia, an organisation providing computing resources to the million-person nation, publicly rejected Microsoft's offer to put the Windows operating system in its schools and decided to keep its existing open-source Linux systems.
Microsoft's recent donation to South African schools of more than 30,000 software licences, by contrast, was better-received.
"This was generally welcomed, because the donation did not force any exclusivity and allows open-source solutions to be developed and deployed on the computing infrastructure rollout that might have been accelerated by the Microsoft donation," Sibisi said. "When choices are limited, it becomes problematic."
Let the editors know what you think in the Mailroom.
Did you find this article useful?
42 out of 97 people found this useful
Digg
Slashdot
Del.ici.ous
Stumble
Reddit
