ZDNet UK


Skip to Main Content

ZDNet.co.uk - Winner of Best Business Website 2007
  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Blogs
  4. Reviews
  5. Prices
  6. Resources
  7. Community
  8. My ZDNet

 

ZDNet UK RSS Feeds


IT Jobs

Enterprise applications Toolkit

Cruel truth surfaces in the OOXML war

Leader ZDNet.co.uk

Published: 30 Jan 2008 18:03 GMT

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendly
  • Post Comment
Cruel truth surfaces in the OOXML war

"You took my ship by surprise, captain," Von Hellmuth said slowly. "Otherwise…"

His tone hinted at treachery, unfair tactics, a course of conduct outrageous to German honour.

"And what the hell have you been doing all these months," Ericson thought, "except taking people by surprise, stalking them, giving them no chance?" But that idea would not have registered. Instead he smiled ironically and said: "It is war. I am sorry if it is too hard for you."

Von Hellmuth gave him a furious glance, but he did not answer the remark: he saw, too late, that, by complaining of his defeat, he had confessed to weakness.

(The Cruel Sea, Nicholas Monsarrat, 1951)

There is little as revealing as complaints made in anger. Such would seem to be the case with Microsoft, whose frustration with the approval process for Office Open XML (OOXML) has spilled out into accusations of underhand behaviour on the part of IBM. Speaking this week, Nicos Tsilas, senior director of interoperability and IP policy at Microsoft, said of IBM: "They have made this a religious and highly political debate. They are doing this because it is advancing their business model."

Read this

Microsoft: IBM masterminded OOXML failure

The software giant has accused IBM of leading attempts to block the ISO ratification of OOXML 'to harm Microsoft's profit stream'...

Read more +

It is hard to believe that Microsoft of all people, experienced as it is in international standardisation, was hitherto unaware of such practices. But the real revelation comes with Tsilas's quote that "IBM have asked governments to have an open-source, exclusive purchasing policy. Our competitors have targeted this one product — mandating one document format over others to harm Microsoft's profit stream."

Perhaps it is a mere slip of the tongue that has Tsalis mixing up open source with open standards. There are good arguments for and against mandating open source in government — protecting business models or profit streams should not be among them — but open standards are a very different matter. Microsoft has said all along that OOXML will be just as open as OpenDocument Format (ODF). How, then, can adopting the latter "harm Microsoft's profit stream"? And since when has an open standard been "a product"?

Tsilas is admitting, more explicitly than implicitly, that Microsoft's profit depends on it controlling standards and that OOXML is a product designed to do exactly that. The mask has slipped and the nature of this particular war is on display. As Ericson, captain of HMS Compass Rose, might say: we are sorry if it is too hard for you, Microsoft.

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendly Print with HP

Did you find this article useful?
93 out of 96 people found this useful



Company/Topic Alerts

Create a new alert from the list below:











Related Jobs

Junior Credit Risk Analyst - SAS or SPSS - Surrey - 25,000 & Bens

With a focus on continuous improvement, the team has created a suite of tools to evaluate portfolio, assess value and risk, steer collection ...

Lean/ Six Sigma Black Belt/ green belt Automotive North West, 33k

To carry out value stream mapping to identify waste. Value stream mapping. My company is a large T1 Automotive supplier. Experience in Injection ...

SAP Logistics Solution Consultant

Integration architect Required to take responsibility for the delivery of an integrated solution covering all work streams. Would have the capability ...

Featured Talkback

The internet is going to have do a lot of maturing before it is ready for this kind of traffic. Security is always going to be a problem, connectivity is poor, and most business's are unwilling for their employees to have open access.

By: ator1940

Read full story:
Microsoft prepares to take Office online