Advertisement
Promo

Compliance Toolkit

IBM faces lawsuit for blocking exec's move to Apple

Tom Krazit CNET News

Published: 17 Nov 2008 12:44 GMT

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendly
  • Post Comment

Apple's iPhone leader-in-waiting, Mark Papermaster, has filed a countersuit against his former employer in a dispute over a non-compete agreement.

Court documents filed late on Thursday in a federal court in New York claim that IBM's non-compete agreement with Papermaster shouldn't apply to his employment at Apple, since the two companies are not competitors in the arena where Papermaster will be employed.

In October, Apple hired Papermaster to replace outgoing iPod executive Tony Fadell and lead the development of future versions of the iPhone, but IBM is suing to prevent Papermaster from working for Apple for a year.

Papermaster's counterclaim focuses on the clauses of the non-compete agreement, arguing that it is too broad and would not permit Papermaster to work for any technology company anywhere in the world for a year following his departure from IBM.

Read this

Photos: Cracking open Apple's iPhone 3G

Investigating the inner workings of Apple's smartphone...

Read more +

"The 'Business Enterprise' restriction is unreasonably broad in that it purports to restrict Mr Papermaster from going to work for any company that engages in competition with his former business unit to any extent, even if Mr Papermaster will not be working for the part of the company that does so. Likewise, the 'significant competitor or major competitor' prong purports to restrict Mr Papermaster from going to work for one of these companies even if the work that Mr Papermaster will be doing is completely unrelated to the work he was doing at IBM. These provisions are not necessary to protect any legitimate interests of IBM," states the counterclaim.

"The non-competition agreement is also unreasonably broad in that it purports to impose an unreasonably lengthy time limitation. In the world of technology, any trade secrets that Mr Papermaster possesses would lose their value prior to the expiration of a year. The purported geographic scope of the 'Restricted Area' is similarly unreasonable. Mr Papermaster has resided and worked in Austin, Texas, for the past 17 years, yet the language of the non-competition agreement purports to restrict him from working anywhere in the world based on the global scope of IBM's business. Again, these restrictions are not necessary to protect any legitimate interests of IBM," the counterclaim states.

IBM has successfully obtained a preliminary injunction preventing Papermaster from reporting for duty at Apple. The two parties are scheduled to have a status conference regarding the case on Tuesday.

Credit: Apple's Papermaster countersues IBM from CNET News

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendlyPrint with EPSON

Did you find this article useful?


Full Talkback thread

0 comments


Company/Topic Alerts

Create a new alert from the list below:







Video icon

Video

Cloud Watch Special Report

Five cloud computing myths exploded

Five cloud computing myths exploded

Analysis The cloud is providing a fertile habitat for the marketeers and their exaggerated claims. We examine the hokum and debunk the five most frequently peddled misconceptions about the cloud

More Special Reports

Sentry Posts Blog

Motorola Droid Drops Today: Happy Droi...

Motorola Droid Drops Today: Happy Droid Day America! Author: Eric Everson, Mobile Security Expert If you’re wondering what all of the buzz is about with words like Droid and Android... More

Post a comment

Mobile Security Profile: BlackBerry St...

Mobile Security Profile: BlackBerry Storm2 Author: Eric Everson BlackBerry handsets are a staple of office culture; from syncing calendars to sharing business-related data,... More

Post a comment

South Korea plans to fingerprint visit...

The South Korean authorities could fingerprint and photograph foreign visitors from 2012, the Korea Times reported on Tuesday. Barring diplomats and government operatives, all visitors... More

Post a comment


Skip Sub Navigation Links to CNET Brand Links

Help

Become part of the ZDNet community.

Newsletters