SCO admits business risks of IBM lawsuit
Published: 01 Apr 2003 07:43 BST
SCO Group warned in a regulatory filing that its billion-dollar lawsuit alleging that IBM misappropriated trade secrets will be costly and could alienate others in the computing industry.
"Unintended consequences of our lawsuit against IBM may adversely affect our business," the seller of Unix and Linux products warned last week in a regulatory filing that permits two major shareholders to sell all their stock. The shareholders received the stock in 2002 in connection with SCO's efforts to get financial help, including the possibility of finding a buyer.
SCO sued IBM in March, alleging IBM misappropriated trade secrets by taking SCO intellectual property in the Unix operating system and moving it into Linux. The suit also alleges unfair competition, breach of contract and tortuous interference with SCO's business. The company is seeking more than $1bn in the case, has hired high-profile attorney David Boies to pursue the claim and is threatening to revoke IBM's licence to ship its version of Unix, called AIX.
The filing warns of several possible ways the suit could hurt SCO: legal fees are likely to "increase substantially" and revenue from joint ventures with IBM and Big Blue's partners could decrease. In addition, SCO warns that IBM could influence customers to shun SCO products.
"There is also a risk that the lawsuit against IBM will be negatively viewed by participants in our marketplace, and in such event, we may lose support from such participants," SCO warned.
Indeed, the suit has been criticised by some industry analysts and several people in the open-source community that collectively develops Linux. And SuSE, a SCO business partner and another Linux seller, said it is re-evaluating its relationship with SCO.
Last week, IBM took its first formal action, moving the suit from Utah state court to federal court in that state. The move was possible because IBM is incorporated in New York, whereas SCO is incorporated in Delaware.
"Since the parties are incorporated in different states, both parties are entitled to have their dispute heard in a federal rather than a state court," said John Ferrell, an intellectual property attorney with Carr & Ferrell.
SCO's warning about the lawsuit's side effects appears in a list of risk disclosures that companies must provide to investors. The filing also permits two major shareholders to sell a total of one million shares of SCO's 12.2 million outstanding shares of stock.
The first shareholder is Vista.com chief executive John R. Wall, who obtained a 6.6 percent stake, or 800,000 shares, of SCO stock. Wall received the stock in connection with a transaction involving a SCO investment in Vista.com, a SCO licence to market Vista.com's services and a $1m convertible note SCO acquired that is payable by Vista.com. The transaction took place in the quarter ended on 31 October, according to SCO's annual report.
The second is Morgan Keegan & Co., an investment banking firm that in August received a warrant for 1.6 percent of SCO, or 200,000 shares. SCO retained the firm to explore and possibly execute plans that included finding, financing or selling SCO to another company, according to SCO's filing for the quarter ended on 31 January.
Under the agreement, Morgan Keegan would get between 1 percent and 6 percent of money raised. If SCO is acquired or acquires another company, Morgan Keegan would receive the greater of $250,000 or 2 percent of the transaction price, according to the filing.
SCO looked at being acquired and at raising finances for three or four months last year, "but we turned that aside in December or January as we got cash-flow positive," chief financial officer Bob Bench said in an interview. Now the company is looking more at acquisitions of smaller companies, he said.
"We have some growth internally, but we'd like to grow faster doing acquisition of technologies and smaller companies," Bench said.
In a separate filing on Monday, the company announced its annual stockholder meeting will be on 16 May, when the company plans to officially change its name from Caldera International to SCO Group.
Let the editors know what you think in the Mailroom.
Did you find this article useful?
50 out of 104 people found this useful
- Share this article:
