Email flow can show company power structure
Published: 25 Mar 2003 09:49 GMT
Figuring out a company's power and communication structure may be as simple as examining patterns of email exchanges, according to new research by some Hewlett-Packard scientists.
In the study, researchers attempted to identify different formal and informal communities within an organisation by graphing mail flow. Researchers Joshua Tyler, Dennis Wilkinson and Bernardo Huberman studied emails sent between any two of the 485 workers at Hewlett-Packard labs over a two-month period, examining 185,773 relevant emails in the process.
The researchers said graphing email flow not only correctly identified communities within the organisation, but it also provided insight into who the leaders of those groups were. It also helped to identify informal communities that arise when people need to communicate across departments or work collaboratively on projects. What's more, it took just a few hours to analyse the data and identify the groups and their leaders, the study said.
"The power of this method for identifying communities and leadership is in its automation," the researchers wrote. "We have found that it does an effective job of uncovering communities of practice with nothing more than email log ("to:" and "from:") data."
Because it can be captured and stored, many scientists are eyeing email as a tool to quantify exchanges that in the past have taken place in hallways or meetings. The researchers in this study said email flow could provide a window into the communications structure of an organisation.
"Given its ubiquity, it is a promising resource for tapping into the dynamics of information within organisations and for extracting the hidden patterns of collaboration and leadership that are at the heart of communities of practice," the study said.
On a practical level, managers, for example, might use information gleaned from email studies to help businesses run more smoothly by making sure teams are communicating effectively and determining who is collaborating on certain projects.
The HP researchers examined the headers of the emails they studied to determine who was corresponding with whom. They then used an algorithm that partitions the graph into discrete communities, progressively weeding out correspondence across communities, in order to identify separate groups.
They then interviewed individuals who worked in the lab, asking them to compare the computerised results with the actual department and team structure of the organisation. The researchers said that all 16 people interviewed about the process, for the most part, affirmed that the communities identified through email exchanges reflected reality, including groups that weren't officially part of the corporate structure.
The researchers acknowledge that the application of the finding could raise privacy concerns, but they note that the subject of the email is not necessary in order to identify the power structure of an organisation.
Let the editors know what you think in the Mailroom.
Did you find this article useful?
49 out of 111 people found this useful
Digg
Slashdot
Del.ici.ous
Stumble
Reddit
