ZDNet UK


Skip to Main Content

  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Blogs
  4. Reviews
  5. Jobs
  6. Resources
  7. Community
  8. My ZDNet

 

ZDNet UK RSS Feeds


Online business Toolkit

Complete privacy 'does not exist', says Google

Stephen Shankland CNET News.com

Published: 31 Jul 2008 09:50 BST

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendly
  • Post Comment

Google's Street View service didn't invade a Pittsburgh couple's privacy, the search giant said in a response to the couple's April lawsuit over the matter.

"Plaintiffs' privacy claims fail, among other reasons, because the view of a home from the driveway that can be seen by any visitor, delivery person, or telephone repairman is not private," the company said in response to the suit, according to a copy posted at The Smoking Gun. Google seeks to dismiss the claim in its filing.

"Today's satellite-image technology means that... complete privacy does not exist," Google said in its response to the complaint. "Plaintiffs live in the 21st century United States, where every step upon private property is not deemed by law to be an actionable trespass... Unless there is a clear expression such as a gate, fence, or 'keep out' sign indicating that the public is not permitted to enter, anyone may approach a home by a walkway, driveway, or any other route commonly used by visitors, without liability for trespass."

Aaron and Christine Boring sued Google on 2 April in Allegheny County, arguing that Google's "reckless conduct" in driving down a private road and publishing the resulting photos caused "mental suffering" and hurt the value of their home. The two are seeking more than $25,000 (£12,500) in damages.

Google also takes issue with the Borings' approach to the matter. "When plaintiffs discovered these images, rather than using the simple removal option Google affords, they sued Google for invasion of privacy, trespass, negligence, and conversion.

"Plaintiffs seek damages form 'mental suffering' and diminished property value supposedly caused by the public accessibility of the photos. They claim these injuries even though similar photos of their home were already publicly available on the internet, and even though they drew exponentially greater attention to the images in question by filing and publicising the lawsuit while choosing not to remove the images of their property from the Street View service," Google said in the response.

Google Maps's satellite and street-level views have raised some privacy concerns. In response to one type of concern, Google now blurs faces visible in Street View.

Credit: Google: No such thing as complete privacy from CNET News.com

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendlyPrint with Konica

Did you find this article useful?
7 out of 7 people found this useful


Full Talkback thread

0 comments


Company/Topic Alerts

Create a new alert from the list below:






Sentry Posts Blog

Police seize phone-gun

Italian police have seized a gun disguised as a mobile phone, according to a report on Gizmodo. The phone can hold four bullets, and is powerful enough to kill somebody. Gizmodo... More

3 comments

Gov't loses a PC a week

The government averaged losing one PC per week over the last year, according to figures collated by the Conservatives. A Friday report by the Press Association said that Tory front-bencher... More

1 comment

The Technological Singularity

Are we approaching a point when machines may wake up and become self or seemingly self aware? Vernor Vinge in 1993 seemed to think so. He refered to this event as the "technological... More

4 comments

Google Chrome

Roundup: Full coverage of the Google Chrome launch

The search giant has launched a beta of its own open-source browser, sending a clear challenge to Microsoft in the way it lets users work with applications More

Blog: Google Chrome has Microsoft's code inside, says MS manager

And furthermore, he says, that's a good thing... More

Blog: Google Chrome — nine things we've found since launch

Google must be very happy with the coverage Chrome has gathered. But it's not all good news... More