Online business Toolkit

Turbulence in Tunisia

Tags:
Freedom Of Information,
Human Rights,
Government,
Tunisia

Declan McCullagh CNET News

Published: 21 Nov 2005 14:55 GMT

A civil liberties watchdog made headlines three years ago when it named Tunisian President Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali a "predator of press freedom".

After Tunisia was chosen to host a high-profile Internet summit, though, Ben Ali pledged to halt practices described by Human Rights Watch as "constant and credible reports of torture" used on Tunisians who publicly criticise the government.

Ben Ali's administration distributed brochures to all attendees of the United Nations' WSIS in Tunis, Tunisia, this week stressing that press freedom is respected. An official government history says "Ben Ali made Tunisia a pioneer country in the protection of human rights".

That hasn't exactly happened. French journalist Christophe Boltanski, who had arrived early to write about Ben Ali's civil-liberties record, was stabbed in an assault by four men and not aided by nearby police. On Thursday, Tunisian police barred the head of Reporters Without Borders from exiting the plane to attend WSIS.

Political and sex-themed Web sites continue to be blocked. Yezzi.org, created last month as an online demonstration against Ben Ali's regime, says it was blocked 18 hours after its launch. Human Rights Watch said in a new report that email accounts and Internet cafes are strictly controlled and encryption is banned.

ZDNet UK's sister site, CNET News.com, interviewed Sean O'Siochru, coordinator of a non-profit organisation called Communication Rights in the Information Society, based in Dublin, Ireland.

Q: You've followed this situation closely. Would you call President Ben Ali a "predator of press freedom?"
A: I've worked in Turkmenistan. If you want to see the worst press predators, go there. Tunisia isn't even the worst Arab country. But there is no question that the human rights situation here is very bad. It became worse in the time leading up to the summit. We had hoped that the country would have made a serious effort in advance.

How has the WSIS summit addressed online civil liberties?
We would have hoped that a world summit on the information society would underline and strengthen those human rights that specially relate to the dissemination of information. We have not found — in fact you will find no instance of where the existing human rights that relate to the Internet have been strengthened thanks to WSIS. At least they haven't been weakened.

One would have hoped that you could bring United Nations' Universal Declaration of Human Rights into the Information Age. Freedom of information applies to the Internet. Access to information applies.

So you were trying to get the WSIS delegates to mention that the Declaration applies to the Internet, and you couldn't?
There was opposition to reaffirming it. The human rights language that was included in the declaration has not been...

For more, click here...