Amazon.com implicated in CD-import row
Published: 07 Jan 2004 14:10 GMT
British Internet shopping could face an upheaval as the music industry gears up for a legal assault on e-commerce sites based overseas that are selling CDs to UK consumers and businesses.
According to The Financial Times, Web giant Amazon.com is being investigated by the British Phonographic Industry (BPI), which suspects it may be breaking copyright law by shipping CDs from America to British customers.
Two other e-tailers, Play.com and CD Wow, have also been investigated by the BPI. Next month, the BPI will tell the High Court that Hong Kong-based CD Wow is breaking the law by buying CDs in Asia, importing them into Britain, and selling them cheaper than UK-based retailers without the permission of the copyright owners.
Sites such as Play.com and CD Wow are popular with some Web users, as their wares are often significantly cheaper than those of UK-based rivals. Unlike Amazon.com, both sites offer free delivery on top of prices that are typically much lower than the recommended retail price.
But the BPI is expected to argue in court that this action constitutes "parallel importing", where a supplier buys items in one country and ships them into a second country where the items are more expensive, because the brand owner charges a much higher price.
After a high-profile court battle between Tesco and Levis over the sale of cut-price jeans, the European Court of Justice ruled in 2002 that the importation of trademarked goods into European countries for resale was only allowed if the trademark owner has given 'unequivocal, positive consent' to such importation.
According to Amazon.co.uk, there's no suggestion that it is being investigated by the BPI, but a company spokeswoman wasn't able to speak on behalf of Amazon.com -- which is expected to give its view on the issue later on Wednesday. The e-tailer has already insisted that it respects the copyright laws of every country it operates in.
The BPI had also failed to respond to a request for comment at the time of writing.
Did you find this article useful?
83 out of 153 people found this useful
Digg
Slashdot
Del.ici.ous
Stumble
Reddit
Full Talkback thread
14 comments
-
This sounds like The music industry just wants to... Anonymous -
In the new global economy, I can't really see the... David Wright
-
The industry has a choice..allow consumers to buy... Robert Tumbleweed
-
Who looks after the customers best interests? Why... Andy Vernon
-
Regarding the trub amazon is in well at christmas... Anonymous
-
It's the age old thing. If products are cheap enou... Adrian Russell
-
Just a few sticky points for the BPI to consider..... Richard Homerstone
-
Companies in this country do not complain when the... Steve Taylor
-
I buy all my CD's via CD WOW and am grateful for t... Anonymous
-
If the recording companies brought the cost of the... Mrs K Prince
-
If an artist sells a million albums worldwide does... Roger the Lodger
-
Well CD-Wow and the BPI have settled out of court,... Wayne Jones
-
i too buy all my cds from cd wow if i have to pay... julie
-
Disgraceful. The UK recording industry is operatin... Paul Revell
